Categories: Headline / Business/Finance / Money Matters
The Art of Seeing Potential

Every year, thousands of ambitious young professionals apply to business school to learn how to lead. And every year, the most selective programs turn most of them away for not having led.
For years, Harvard Business School told applicants it was looking for a “habit of leadership.” Stanford’s Graduate School of Business evaluates “demonstrated leadership potential.” The typical admit arrives with years of work experience and a record of having already run something: a team, a project, a platoon, a startup.
It sounds like a catch-22. You apply to Harvard or Stanford to learn how to lead, and the schools ask when you have already led.
If you must already be a leader to get in, why go?
Because education nurtures. The schools look for potential that has already shown itself, then spend two years shaping it. Admit based on nature. Then educate to nurture.
Importantly, nature must come before nurture.
This week’s parsha, Toldot, records what happens when a family gets the order backwards.
The Twins
“Vayigdelu hane’arim, vayehi Esav ish yode’a tzayid, ish sadeh, ve’Yaakov ish tam, yoshev ohalim.” The boys grew up; Esav became a skilled hunter, a man of the field, and Yaakov a wholesome man, dwelling in tents (Bereshit 25:27).
Notice the first two words. The Torah describes the difference between the twins only once they were grown.
Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch reads this as the central mistake of Yitzchak and Rivka. While the boys were small, no one paid attention to how different they were. They received the same schooling, the same discipline, the same expectations. Only when they were grown did the gap become visible, and by then it was a chasm. Yaakov thrived in the tent of study. Esav, built for the field, experienced the same curriculum as a cage, and left.
Rav Hirsch does not treat Esav’s nature as the problem. His strength, courage, and drive were raw material. Had his parents asked early how this particular child could be won for the service of G-d, Esav’s might and Yaakov’s spirit could have worked together.
Shlomo HaMelech gave the principle its classic form: “Chanokh la’na’ar al pi darko, gam ki yazkin lo yasur mimena,” educate the child according to his way, and even when he is old, he will not depart from it (Mishlei 22:6).
Not according to the way. According to his.
The Grandfather Who Saw
Yaakov learned the lesson. Decades later, he is the old man whose eyes “were heavy with age, he could not see” (Bereshit 48:10), the same condition as his father when he blessed the wrong son. Yosef places Menashe, the firstborn, at Yaakov’s right hand and Ephraim at his left. Yaakov crosses his hands. “Sikel et yadav” (48:14): he did it deliberately.
Yosef protests. Yaakov answers: “Yadati beni, yadati,” I know, my son, I know (48:19). The younger will be greater.
Same blindness. Opposite outcome. Yitzchak was guided by birth order. Yaakov looked past family rank to who the boys were and who they could become.
The pattern completes at his deathbed. Yaakov blesses twelve sons, and no two blessings match: Yehuda the lion, Yissachar the burdened donkey, Zevulun at the shore, Naftali the swift deer. The Torah sums it up: “Ish asher k’virchato berach otam,” each according to his own blessing he blessed them (49:28).
A blessing, in this sense, is not a gift distributed equally. It is a diagnosis of potential and a push in its direction. It is akin to the MBA that takes the nature and provides it nurture.
Tanach returns to this repeatedly. Shmuel arrives at Yishai’s house, sees the eldest son, and is impressed. G-d corrects him: “Ki ha’adam yir’eh la’einayim, va’Hashem yir’eh lalevav,” man sees what is visible, but G-d sees into the heart (I Shmuel 16:7). The crown goes to the youngest, out with the sheep.
The right person in the right role is not a management fad. It is how the Torah builds a nation.
Measuring Nature
Modern psychology has spent decades trying to assess a person’s nature. One of the most scientifically valid methods is the Big Five model, known by the acronym OCEAN: openness to experience, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, and neuroticism, the inverse of emotional stability. The traits are measurable, stable over a lifetime, and found across cultures. Children differ by nature, and the differences last.
In my companies, we used a related tool, the Predictive Index, which measures four behavioral drives of its own along with cognitive ability. I used it to find potential that a resume could not show. Some of my best hires had no college diploma. What they had was a strong record of real achievement, high ambition, and behavioral and cognitive profiles showing they were very bright, capable, and driven. Diamonds in the rough. A credential filter would have discarded every one of them.
One stands out. She was a Black South African woman who had learned Mandarin and studied aeronautical engineering in China. Back home in South Africa, she could not find work, held back by discrimination as a woman and as a Black person. She took our assessments and scored the best out of over 100 applicants. We hired her. She has been a star ever since.
Prejudice sees the surface. Measurement sees the merit. Blind assessment is what makes a true meritocracy possible.
Picasso and Paint-by-Numbers
The deeper point is not who is smarter. It is what drives people.
Some people love paint-by-numbers. Hand them a knitting pattern and they find satisfaction in executing it perfectly, row after row. They prize structure and consistency. They tend to thrive in accounting and operations, where a skipped step is a defect.
Others are Picasso people. They want the blank canvas, and a fixed pattern bores them. They tend to thrive in product development, sales, and customer service, where no two problems arrive the same way.
Put a Picasso in the controller’s office and you get creative accounting. Put a paint-by-numbers person in charge of the product roadmap and you get last year’s catalog in new colors.
Neither type is better. Each is wasted in the wrong seat. Esav was not a failed Yaakov. He was a potentially great Esav who was never given the chance.
A Direction, Not a Box
The obvious objection is that assessment becomes a cage of its own. The test says you are an introvert, so no one ever considers you for sales.
Yaakov’s blessings answer it. Shimon and Levi receive the harshest words of all. Their anger is condemned, and they will be scattered within Israel (Bereshit 49:7). Yet that same fierceness, redirected, makes Levi the tribe that stands with Moshe at the Golden Calf, and the scattering becomes forty-eight Levite cities spread across the land, serving every tribe.
The blessing did not change their nature. It changed its direction. That is precisely what Rav Hirsch says Esav was denied.
The purpose of understanding a person is to find the environment where he fits best and thrives most.
The school that measures every student against one curriculum. The founder who hires only in his own image. Each repeats Yitzchak’s mistake, with Yitzchak’s good intentions.
Yitzchak gave his sons the same education. Yaakov gave his sons different blessings.
Nature first. Then nurture. Then the blessing.


November 13, 2026 







