יום רביעי, 18 נובמבר 2026Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Follow Us
יום רביעי, ח׳ כסלו תשפ״זWednesday, November 18, 2026
Follow Us

Sections

Categories: / 

An Act of Kindness

By Rabbi Dovid Goldwasser

|

November 18, 2026, 10 AM ET


“And it came to pass in the morning, and behold she was Leah!” (Bereishis 29:25)

Rashi cites the Talmud (Megillah 13b)that when Rachel saw that Leah was being brought for Yaakov, she knew Leah would be humiliated so she transmitted to her the signs that Yaakov had given her. This seems to be a very noble act on Rachel’s part, especially as she would now have to marry Eisav with all his failings.

There is a compelling question, though. Although it was very considerate of Rachel to be concerned that Leah should not be humiliated on the wedding night – when Yaakov discovered that she was not Rachel – how could she be unmindful of the pain she was causing Yaakov? He wanted to marry Rachel, had given her gifts, and had given Rachel certain signs for the wedding night that would confirm that it was she with him.

Also, later on (30:14-15),when Rachel asked Leah for some of the duda’im that Reuven had brought her, Leah responded, “Is it a small matter that you have taken my husband, that you also want to take my son’s duda’im?” How could Leah speak that way to Rachel, who had been so kind to her and imparted the “signs” to Leah thereby enabling her to be Yaakov’s wife?

This can be clarified by studying the Talmud’s discussion of this matter. The Talmud cites the pasuk (Bereishis 29:12)that Yaakov told Rachel that he was Lavan’s brother. Yet he was, in fact, Lavan’s nephew. How is this explained? When Yaakov asked Rachel to marry him, she told him that Lavan was a swindler and Yaakov would not be able to outwit him. Yaakov replied, “I am his brother,” i.e. in deception. “Is that permitted?” asked Rachel. “It is,” responded Yaakov, “as it says [Shmuel II, 22:27], ‘… with the perverse you deal crookedly.’”

Yaakov asked how Lavan would try to deceive him, and Rachel explained that she had an older sister, and Lavan would try to give her in Rachel’s place. Yaakov therefore gave her certain signs she should use that would verify she was Rachel.

When the wedding night arrived, and Rachel saw that Leah would, indeed, be marrying Yaakov, Rachel did not want Leah to be embarrassed, so she gave her the signs that Yaakov and she had agreed upon. Thus, it was only when morning arrived, “Behold she was Leah.”

By giving the signs to Leah, Rachel did not “cause” Yaakov to have pain. His marriage to Leah would have taken place regardless of her actions. She merely relieved Leah of any embarrassment.

Leah, at the same time, was not especially grateful to Rachel, because she would have ended up married to Yaakov, regardless of whether or not she knew the signs. In truth, actually, Rachel did not demand any gratitude. Leah didn’t know that Rachel had given her the signs known only to her and Yaakov. Leah thought that Rachel had merely taught her the halachos for a married woman to know – hilchos niddah, challah and hadlakas ner (which was what Yaakov and Rachel had designated as the signs).

R’ Ovadiah M’Bartenura comments that the Mishnain Avos (1:17),“I have found nothing better for oneself than silence,” is referring to one who has been shamed. We learn (Shabbos 88b),“Those who are insulted … and do not respond, about them the verse states [Shoftim 5:31]‘those who love Him shall be as the sun going forth in its might.’” He has exhibited great restraint and moral character by not responding in kind. The Orchos Tzaddikim writes that if one hears his shame and remains silent, he is considered to be on a very high spiritual level. The sefer Reishis Chachmahdescribes it as a mitzvah gedolah. So great is the concept of remaining silent in the face of shame that we pray three times a day in the Shemone Esrei,“Let my soul be silent to those who curse me.”

The great R’ Menachem Nachum Kaplan used to walk through the city every erev Shabbos to encourage the business owners to close their stores and establishments for Shabbos.

Once, he encountered one of the maskilim who began to deride him. “Who appointed you prince and judge over us?” He was rude and insulting as he mocked R’ Menachem.

The people of the city were appalled and wanted to retaliate; however, R’ Menachem ordered them to stand down, and not to do anything, in order to avoid any chilul Hashem. The wife of the maskil also came to R’ Menachem to apologize for her husband’s insolence.

A number of weeks later, the maskil was once again in the presence of R’ Menachem Nachum. Suddenly, the police swooped in and arrested the maskil for some offense he had committed against the government. He was tried and sentenced to two years in prison. His livelihood and his family were in dire straits, and the maskil recognized that the hand of Hashem had intervened because he had shamed the great gaon and tzaddik R’ Menachem Nachum.

At this point the wife of the maskil once again came to R’ Menachem and cried about her family’s difficult financial plight because her husband was sitting in prison. She stated that her husband genuinely regretted his disparagement of the tzaddik. When R’ Menachem heard about the family’s problems, he immediately collected a generous sum of money to support the family. He was also able to arrange better food and privileges for the man in prison, and he finally was able to organize some wealthy people in the city to redeem the maskil from prison.

When the maskil grasped the extent of what R’ Menachem had done for him, he became one of his devoted chassidim, and a philanthropic individual who supported Torah study and communal chesed activities.

Serials

Persuaded - Chapter XIII

By Barbara Bensoussan

View all

Sponsored Posts

cross